No bake peanut butter pie, made famous by the Amish, is simple to make and easy to customize by changing the crust and toppings used.
This smooth and creamy pie is a fan favorite around here. People love it so much I usually have to make two at a time whenever we have a party of any sorts.
I even turn this pie into a chocolate peanut butter pie just by using an oreo crust! No matter which crust you choose to use, your guests will be talking about this pie long after the meal is over.
HOW TO MAKE A HOMEMADE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
Graham Cracker Crust
Graham cracker crust seems to be the most popular one used in most restaurants and recipes. Not my favorite, but it still makes a great pie.
Traditional Pastry Crust
A traditional pie crust can be used. It needs to be blind baked before use. I prefer a traditional crust to a graham cracker crust. You can even make a peanut butter flavored pastry pie crust.
I have not tried to make one of these, any long-time readers already know traditional pie crust is my kitchen nemesis. If you eat a pie here and it has a crust like that, you can be sure it was a premade store bought one!
Peanut Butter Cookie or Oreo Cookie Pie Crust
Making cookie crumbs with a food processor is really simple. If you don’t have one just put the cookies in a sealed plastic bag and crush with a rolling pin. Make sure there isn’t any air in the or it will pop open and spray cookie crumbs everywhere. Ask me how I know………
The smaller the crumbs, the tighter the crust will be. Refrigerate the crust after assembling so that crust has a chance to firm up. This will make it easier to spread the filling without pulling up bits of crust.
The cookie crust can also be baked if desired. Bake it in a preheated 350 Degree F oven for 7 to 10 minutes or just until you start to smell it. Lightly baked is all you are striving for. It isn’t necessary though, I don’t do it because it’s a no-bake pie.
The best method for pressing cookie crumb and graham cracker crusts into an even layer is to use a cup that has a flat bottom and has been sprayed with baking spray.
After adding the buttered crumbs to the pie pan, spread them out over the bottom and up the sides.
Gently press the cup along the bottom of the pie pan and use the side of the cup to press along the sides of the pie pan.
Smooth Peanut Butter vs Chunky Peanut Butter
You can use smooth or chunky peanut butter when making a peanut butter pie. It’s a personal preference thing. I usually use smooth peanut butter because it’s what I have on hand.
You can use homemade peanut butter in this pie too. Make sure the peanut butter is mixed well before using and you might find you need to add 1/4 to 1/2 cup of additional powdered sugar to the filling so it will set up.
Whipped cream vs Whipped Topping (Cool Whip)
This recipe calls for homemade whipped cream but thawed whipped topping can be used. Replace the heavy whipping cream and 1/4 cup of granulated sugar in the recipe with 3 cups of whipped topping.
Using whipped topping and a premade graham cracker crust makes this recipe super-fast and easy.
HOW TO SERVE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
Peanut butter pie can be served just like you would any other dessert or snack. You might want to consider cutting this pie into smaller pieces because it is so rich, a little sliver will go a long way even for those with the biggest sweet tooth!
I cut my pie into 12 slices and offer several topping choices and let guests top their own piece. I like crushed peanuts and chocolate sauce on mine.
- Homemade Whipped Cream
- Milk Chocolate Chips
- Peanut Butter Chips
- Mini Nutter Butters
- Crushed Peanuts
- Crushed Cookies
- Chocolate Syrup
- Mini Peanut Butter Cups
- Chocolate Ganache
- Chopped Reese’s Pieces
- Chopped M & M’s
- Strawberry Syrup – make a peanut butter and jelly flavored pie!
HOW TO STORE PEANUT BUTTER PIE
Peanut Butter Pie should be stored covered in the refrigerator. It will last for about 3 days before the filling starts to get gummy and the crust gets soggy.
It can be frozen too! Freeze the leftover pie and then placed into a freezer safe container or baggie. Remove as much excess air as possible.
To freeze individual servings of peanut butter pie cut the pie before freezing and set onto a plate or baking sheet without allowing the pie pieces to touch. Once they have frozen solid, wrap them individually in plastic wrap and place into a freezer safe container or plastic bag.
Peanut Butter Pie can stay in the freezer for about 3 months before the quality starts to fade.
To thaw, remove it from the freezer and the container and place into the refrigerator until softened. For quicker thawing, set the pie out at room temperature. I have even seen it eaten frozen, so there’s that.
Don’t forget to rate the recipe, follow us on social media, and sign-up to receive our latest recipe alerts.
MORE RECIPES THAT USE PEANUT BUTTER
Buckeyes – Chocolate Dipped Peanut Butter Balls
Dirty Buckeyes – Bacon covered Buckeyes
Peanut Butter Icing – starts with canned icing
Traditional pastry pie crust that has been blind baked, graham cracker pie crust, or any store bought pie crust can be substituted for the cookie crust in the recipe. Peanut Butter Pie is fairly rich and is best served in slices smaller than other standard pie slices. We find cutting the pie into 12 slices is a good size.
Serving Size: 1/12 of pie
Amount Per Serving:Calories: 455 Total Fat: 32.68g Saturated Fat: 13.86g Cholesterol: 53mg Sodium: 311mg Carbohydrates: 35.75g Fiber: 1.5g Sugar: 26g Protein: 8.54g
Traditional pastry pie crust that has been blind baked, graham cracker pie crust, or any store bought pie crust can be substituted for the cookie crust in the recipe.
Peanut Butter Pie is fairly rich and is best served in slices smaller than other standard pie slices. We find cutting the pie into 12 slices is a good size.