25 Cookies That Aren’t Chocolate
Amazon Associates Disclosure We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
An array of cookies that cater to every craving. This collection delivers a symphony of flavors and textures from classic favorites like Snickerdoodles and Butter Balls to unique creations like Lemon Curd and Cookie Butter Cookies. Indulge in the warmth of fall with Iced Pumpkin and Pumpkin Biscotti, or relish the elegance of Italian Wedding and Vanilla Swirl Cookies.
Italian Wedding Cookies
Italian Wedding Cookies – delicate, buttery almond-flavored bites coated in powdered sugar. These cookies are also called Italian Butter Balls, a name that echoes their delightful nature. Distinct from their Mexican Wedding Cookies counterpart, this recipe features a unique twist with granulated sugar in the cookie dough and almonds instead of pecans. Get the Recipe: Italian Wedding Cookies
Cookie Butter Cookies
Cookie Butter Cookies – a unique blend reminiscent of peanut butter but made from cookie butter, these buttery treats offer a creamy, sweet, slightly spicy, and smooth flavor profile. The outcome is a tender cookie that effortlessly melts in your mouth with each indulgent bite. Get the Recipe: Cookie Butter Cookies
Lemon Curd Cookies
Lemon Curd Cookies – delectable bites of sunshine that bring joy to any occasion. Combining the rich flavors of butter, sugar, and zesty lemon, these cookies offer a delightful crunch and vibrant taste. Their ease of preparation is a highlight – no chilling required, bringing a burst of sunshine to your mouth in under 30 minutes. Get the Recipe: Lemon Curd Cookies
Cake Mix Cookies
Cake Mix Cookies – a delightful, simple, delicious recipe requiring just three easy-to-find ingredients. Perfect for various occasions, from parties and Christmas gatherings to Valentine’s Day celebrations or personal indulgences. These cookies, made with cake mix, promise a light and fluffy texture that’s hard to resist. An evolution of a classic back-of-the-box recipe, these cookies hold a special place in baking variations. While red velvet is a favorite, you can explore any cake flavor. Get the Recipe: Cake Mix Cookies
Pie Crust Cookies
Easy Pie Crust Cookies – a delightful creation born from just four simple ingredients: butter, sugar, cinnamon, and pie crust. This recipe is a favorite for its quick preparation, affordability, and universal appeal. Perfect for cookie platters and delightful as sweet snacks at gatherings, these cookies hold a special place in any spread. They’re also affectionately known as rollie pollies or pigtails when crafted from leftover pie dough scraps. Get the Recipe: Pie Crust Cookies
Pumpkin Biscotti
Step into the heart of pumpkin season with a delightful Pumpkin Biscotti recipe. While pumpkin spice lattes dominate coffee shop counters, a world of fall flavors is waiting to grace your table. These simple biscotti, easy to prepare, offer a satisfying crunch and the essence of autumn in every bite. The recipe allows room for creativity – you can enhance the deliciousness with added ingredients or revel in the classic pumpkin flavor. Get the Recipe: Pumpkin Biscotti
Honey Cookies
Honey Cookies – a straightforward recipe designed for those seeking a delightful treat without the fuss. You can create cookies with minimal ingredients boasting a gentle floral and fruity essence from the honey. These cookies aim for a balanced chewiness without being overly soft. Get the Recipe: Honey Cookies
Pistachio Cookies
This Cream Cheese Pistachio Cookies recipe is a highly sought-after treat known for its soft, dense texture and exceptional flavor. These cookies prompt curious inquiries like “What’s in these?” due to their captivating taste. The answer is cream cheese, which provides a unique texture and subtle notes. Get the Recipe: Pistachio Cookies
Pumpkin Cookies
Pumpkin Cookies – the epitome of fall flavors that always find a warm welcome. These cookies take the beloved pumpkin cookie up a notch with a luscious vanilla glaze or penuche frosting, creating an irresistible treat. The simplicity of making these cookies adds to their charm, and the recipe is easily scalable for larger batches. The addition of canned pumpkin grants these cookies a delightful bright orange hue, making them an ideal choice for Halloween festivities. Get the Recipe: Pumpkin Cookies
Elephant Ear Cookies
Elephant Ear Cookies – a wonderfully uncomplicated 3-ingredient recipe for those seeking a quick and delightful treat. Inspired by the French Palmiers, aptly named for their palm tree shape, these cookies offer elegance without the fuss. Enjoy them solo, or elevate the experience with ice cream, a drizzle of honey, or a splash of chocolate sauce. Their simplicity invites endless experimentation, making these cookies a canvas for creative indulgence. Get the Recipe: Elephant Ear Cookies
Butter Balls
Butter Balls – known by names like Snowball Cookies or Russian Tea Cakes. These delightful morsels are an ideal addition to cookie trays, cherished by everyone. With just five simple ingredients and a quick 10-minute bake time, making butter balls is a breeze, perfect even for busy schedules. Butter Balls are similar to Mexican Wedding Cookies, also known as Mexican Wedding Cakes. The name preference often varies based on geographic location. While weddings don’t always feature these cookies, they are a staple on holiday cookie trays. Get the Recipe: Butter Balls
Peanut Butter Bar Cookies
Peanut Butter Bar Cookies take the classic appeal of old-fashioned peanut butter cookies and transform them into convenient bars. Crafting these Peanut Butter Cookie Bars takes under 30 minutes, offering a speedy route to indulgence. These bars provide a traybake-style snacking experience that’s perfect for various occasions. From satisfying hungry kids returning from school to being a hit at bake sales or tucked into lunchboxes, these squares of goodness promise to please. Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Cookie Bars
Molasses Cookies
Molasses Cookies, where the festive spices of the holiday season mingle to create a soft and chewy gingerbread-like delight. If there’s one cookie that deserves your baking attention this year, it’s undeniably this one! Molasses cookies are cherished in the heart of holiday traditions, anticipated by friends and family annually. Get the Recipe: Molasses Cookies
Pecan Tassies
Pecan Tassies! These petite desserts boast a cream cheese crust and a gooey pecan filling to satisfy your sweet cravings. If you’re a fan of the delightful combination of nuts and sweetness, this recipe is tailored for you. The best part? These treats are so easy to whip up, making them a go-to choice for regular indulgence. Get the Recipe: Pecan Tassies
German Almond Cookies
Almond Icebox Cookies, where softness meets irresistible appeal. With a touch of cinnamon and a balanced sweetness, these cookies capture the hearts of all who taste them. Keeping them in the refrigerator allows for the convenience of slicing and baking whenever the craving for freshly baked cookies strikes. These German-inspired treats are a hit. They are loved for their softness, mild sweetness, and perfect companionship with coffee, tea, hot chocolate, or milk. Get the Recipe: German Almond Cookies
Peanut Butter Cookies
This single recipe is your gateway to an array of delectable treats. This recipe’s versatility knows no bounds, from the timeless peanut butter cookies to the adored peanut butter blossoms, affectionately known as Hershey Kiss cookies, and even charming elf-sized delights. Get the Recipe: Peanut Butter Cookies
Ricotta Cookies
Italian Ricotta Cookies are a beloved treat that everyone adores! The recipe creates soft, tender, and fluffy sprinkle cookies with a delightful cake-like texture. These cookies are so delicious they’ll have people wondering if they came from a bakery. Known by various names like Italian Sprinkle Cookies, Italian Christmas Cookies, and Ricotta Cheese Cookies, these treats offer a taste of pure joy. Get the Recipe: Ricotta Cookies
Peppermint Cookies
Soft sugar cookies filled with peppermint bits, topped with peppermint buttercream, and crushed candies. These cookies are highly sought-after during the holiday season. Despite their impressive appearance, they’re easy to whip up. They can be decorated with icing and peppermint sprinkles or enjoyed without toppings. No matter how they’re served, they make an excellent companion to hot chocolate or coffee. Get the Recipe: Peppermint Cookies
Chewy Sprinkle Cookies
Soft and Chewy Sprinkle Cookies – a delightful treat that brings fun to any cookie tray. Making these cookies is a breeze, and their appearance is simply beautiful. They’ll likely remind you of the colorful rainbow sprinkle polvorones found at a nearby Mexican Bakery, but with a notable difference – these cookies are less crumbly. These cookies are an excellent addition to any gathering with their eye-catching look and texture. Get the Recipe: Chewy Sprinkle Cookies
Swirl Cookies
Vanilla Swirl Cookies are sugary goodness with a twist of colorful dough. These cookies are super easy to make, and here’s the best part – you can keep them in the refrigerator, then slice and bake whenever you want! You can mix and match colors for extra fun. So, whether it’s a sweet craving or a burst of color you need, these cookies have you covered! Get the Recipe: Swirl Cookies
Sugar Cookies
Easily bake impeccable cut-out sugar cookies every time, skipping the chilling process! This recipe delivers soft and durable cookies, making them an ideal canvas for adding decorative icing. Create your perfect cut-out sugar cookies without the hassle. These cookies balance tenderness and sturdiness, making them perfect for decorating with delicious icing and colorful sprinkles. Get the Recipe: Cut-Out Sugar Cookies
Pecan Pie Bars
Southern Pecan Pie bars, where a classic dessert transforms into delightful pecan pie bar cookies. This recipe takes the best of pecan pie and elevates it into a handy bar form. Imagine a delectable shortbread crust that’s sweet, crispy, and crowned with everyone’s beloved pecan pie filling. Say goodbye to the days of serving runny pecan pies. Get the Recipe: Pecan Pie Bars
Snickerdoodles
This is a must-have in every recipe collection: the Snickerdoodles Recipe. This recipe yields wonderfully soft, pillowy, and chewy cookies – a true delight for all. Who could resist the allure of these tender, buttery treats coated in cinnamon and sugar? They are ideal for gifting or keeping all to yourself. If there’s one cookie that’s sure to please everyone, it’s the classic Snickerdoodle. Get the Recipe: Snickerdoodles
Beginner Cookies
Introducing Beginner Cookies – a special treat designed for those new to cooking. These cookies feature graham crackers filled with frosting and are super easy to assemble. Whether using homemade buttercream or store-bought frosting, it’s a kid-friendly delight that requires minimal supervision. Perfect as an after-school snack, this recipe is special because it encourages young cooks to step into the kitchen and start building kitchen skills. Basic recipes like this one are the foundation for every cook’s journey. These treats have a long history in the family, with fond memories of a relative bringing them to dessert gatherings. It’s a delightful way to build confidence in the kitchen and enjoy the delicious results. Get the Recipe: Beginner Cookies
Pecan Chewies
Pecan Chewies pair beautifully with tea or coffee any time of year. You can whip this nutty sweet treat with just one bowl, a few ingredients, and 30 minutes. Pecan Chewies recipes vary widely, much like the cherished creations of Southern grannies. This version stands out with its slightly chewy edges and a soft, well-set middle. Get the Recipe: Pecan Chewies
More From Pear Tree Kitchen
Find more recipes from appetizers to desserts and everything in between. MORE RECIPES
Elizabeth (Beth) Mueller
Elizabeth (Beth) Mueller is a food journalist, CEO of Pear Tree Kitchen, and co-creator of Food Blogger Help. She also has a bachelor’s degree in philosophy and a registered nurse licensed in the State of Oklahoma. When she has free time between writing, blogging, and cooking, she can be found volunteering as an RN with the Oklahoma Medical Reserve Corps.